Guidebook on Reclaiming Sarawak NCR Lands in Courts

Practical information is often necessary for communities resorting to the court process (Civil Litigation) to reclaim Native Customary Rights (NCR) Lands.  The below guidebook is SACCESS’s first attempt to better inform and prepare Native Customary Rights (NCR) landowners in Sarawak who want to use the Malaysian civil courts to seek declaration of their lawful rights over their NCR Lands.

Over the past two decades, there is growing awareness among NCR Landowners of the need to file claims in the Malaysian High Courts to protect their NCR Land. There is also growing awareness that the recent Sarawak Government’s attempt to survey selected NCR Lands, purportedly to issue land titles and establish official recognition, is merely an attempt to subdue the rising disgruntlement and apprehension amongst the native landowners – as compare to doing the survey in order to recognise the people’s land rights fully. In fact, native landowners experience the continual violation of their rights to NCR Land, as the survey has left out more communal lands. Thus, many landowners have brought NCR Land cases to the attention of lawyers.

But resources are limited, in particular dedicated and experienced lawyers in Sarawak dealing with NCR Land cases on pro bono basis. Communities (as most are) often don’t fully understand how the courts work. So lawyers have to do much repeated explanation when communities come to them wanting to seek court redress in defending their land rights. With the help of this guidebook for communities, we hope it will reduce the time needed by lawyers and NGOs especially in the preliminary and preparatory stages. Furthermore, it is hoped that the communities will see their crucial roles in the court process, instead of thinking it is all in the lawyers’ hands.

This guide begins by providing the essential information to native landowners who plan to file their NCR Land in courts. It is expected that communities can be better prepared once they know the basics. This guide draws examples from cases won (and lost) earlier. The judgements recognising and declaring communities’ rights to land may be encouraging for other communities to know that they are entitled to the rights of access to the Courts to protect those rights. In the short and medium terms, without doubt, the Courts are a viable legal recourse to justice. In fact in the continuation of the current political atmosphere, the Courts remain one of the most significant channels to protect NCR Lands.

In order to ensure long term equity and equality, improvement of life and decision making powers, it is important for native landowners to recognize the power of their votes in solving problems affecting communities.

In foregone elections at state and federal levels, the Barisan Nasional (BN) in Sarawak are the ones who have always won, and continue to win, notwithstanding allegations of gerrymandering, fraud, manipulation, bribery and vote-buying. But has the BN government fully implemented what has been pledged and promised to the Sarawak people during the elections and beyond – example, that the governments do not take NCR Lands?

As only the Sarawak State Government can take lands and refuses to recognize the people’s rights completely, and with native landowners voting for the BN – and repeatedly in every election – then they must realize/accept the fact that it is the continuing BN government that is taking their NCR Lands, a trend over the past three decades in Sarawak.

So the role of native landowners, and all Sarawak people, is crucial to enable change to happen – the need to change to a government in Sarawak and Malaysia on the whole that will secure the people’s rights.

This is the first version and we acknowledge there will be limitations in its scope, coverage and details. Furthermore, policies and laws affecting NCR Lands can be frequently changed or amended by the Sarawak Government to reduce recognition of NCR Lands or non-recognition at all. That means information have to be updated from time to time.

We see the struggle for justice, equality and democracy as the responsibilities of all, as one.

In spite of our efforts to be mindful about the use of words and their meanings, essential pronouns to refer to person/persons or things (e.g. we, you, they, us, them, theirs) still cannot be avoided. We ask for these to be considered as English grammar and language, not as creating the “them vs us” situation. We see the struggle for justice, equality and democracy as the responsibilities of all, as one.

We welcome constructive feedback to help make this guidebook a work-in-progress. Ultimately, we hope to improve the guidebook in terms of contents, clarity, details and areas covered and produce a most updated, if not a final version Guidebook. More importantly, with this first English Electronic Version, we hope to have other versions in practical local languages for the ethnically diverse Sarawak NCR Landowners.

Thus, this Guidebook may be freely translated into other languages, provided that no part of the contents changed without our prior permission, SACCESS is acknowledged and a copy (preferably soft copy) of the translated material is sent to us. We welcome offers to work together withSACCESS on this initiative, if the intent is not related to profit making ventures.

This Guidebook is compiled and written by Wee Aik Pang. The information herein is based on past experiences and careful inquiries into this topic. This guidebook has been prepared in close consultation with the land-rights lawyers from the firm of Messrs Baru Bian Advocates and Solicitors. We thank Carol Yong for her support in reviewing and editing this Guidebook. However, the author and reviewer/editor are fully responsible for errors of fact or interpretation in this Guidebook.

Unless otherwise stated, this manual is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 Malaysia License (For details, visit: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.5/my/). For permission to do anything beyond the scope of this license, please contact SACCESS. Download and Print from GUIDEBOOK ON RECLAIMING SARAWAK NCR LANDS IN COURTS

For more information on human rights issues in Borneo, please visit: https://borneoproject.org/who-we-are/borneo/human-rights